Here is the guide for the best ponzu sauce substitutes. Like a lot of Japanese seasonings, ponzu sauce has a complex flavor profile. Generally it combined sweetness, bitterness, and the classic Japanese umami flavor.
Typically, you’ll find the best ponzu sauce in Japan, or at local Japanese restaurants, but what if you want something similar at home?
Fortunately for you, we’ve determined that the best substitute for ponzu sauce is soy sauce. That’s right, as simple as it seems, soy sauce is one of the best things you can use instead of ponzu sauce. Soy sauce is actually a key ingredient in many ponzu sauce recipes, and although it doesn’t taste exactly the same, it will provide a similar flavor. Soy sauce is also very versatile, you can use it in place of ponzu in a broad variety of dishes.
What is Ponzu Sauce?
Ponzu is a Japanese sauce that is not unlike vinegar. It’s somewhat salty and tart, packed with umami flavor. Generally, the main ingredient in a ponzu recipe is citrus, but there are as many recipes for ponzu are there are people who love making it.
The word “zu”, as in “ponzu”, is the Japanese for vinegar. In ponzu, as with other Japanese foods, vinegar is actually a critical component of the recipe. It provides acidity - a great flavor enhancer - to many dishes and it can work as a standalone condiment if you like.
Like many other Japanese condiments, ponzu, when used in moderation, is quite healthy. It stores easily in the fridge and is easy to work with if you decide to cook with it.
Why Would You Substitute Ponzu Sauce?
Ponzu sauce is delicious, so why would you want to use something else? Sometimes, you - or one of your guests - might prefer a different taste. The dense, complex flavor of ponzu isn’t for everyone, and that’s OK.
It’s also pretty rare to find real ponzu outside of Japan or in Japanese specialty shops. It can even be tricky to find in other parts of Asia. If your local Asian grocer has no ponzu available, you’ll be looking for a suitable substitute. Fans of Japanese food will love knowing that there’s a delicious flavor substitute available.
Ponzu Sauce Substitutes
Best Substitute: Soy Sauce
We strongly recommend soy sauce as the best substitute for ponzu sauce. The two are similar in application, if not in flavor. They are both very versatile, complement the same types of food well, and can not only bring their own flavor to a dish but highlight key flavors of other ingredients, too.
Soy sauce also works as a great substitute for ponzu sauce because you can use the broad array of soy sauce flavors and flavor combos to approximate the experience of great ponzu.
For example, you could take soy sauce and add a dash of vinegar. This will bring the characteristic acidity of ponzu sauce to your soy sauce, and make it perfect for dipping. For sweetness, you could always try mirin or some sugar. Balancing sweetness, acidity, and umami, is how we achieve great flavors, and it’s the flavor profile of ponzu, too
If you prefer to use a different type of acid, you can try lemon juice. Lemon juice also has some natural sugar so it will taste fresher and a little sweeter than vinegar will if you add it to your soy sauce. Lemon juice also has a pleasant, fresh aroma when compared to the stronger sour smell of vinegar. As we mentioned above, authentic ponzu sauce contains citrus as a critical ingredient, so using the juice of a lemon or lime with soy sauce is a great way to approximate the experience of ponzu sauce.
Of course, if you like citrus, and you want something even sweeter, you could use orange juice instead. Orange juice is far sweeter than lemon juice so this could be a great flavor combo with soy sauce.
This versatility and compatibility with a wide variety of other ingredients is exactly what makes soy sauce the perfect substitute for ponzu sauce.
Best Substitute If You’re Short on Time: Shoyu
Shoyu, like soy sauce, is a widely used component of most ponzu sauce. If you don’t have much time available to try different soy sauce combinations, you can use shoyu. Shoyu is often used in commercially available ponzu sauce to help extend the ponzu’s shelf life, and as a result its innate flavor is part of typical ponzu sauce.
Shoyu is a great substitute for ponzu sauce, and it particularly shines when used as a marinade. Of course, marinades are best reserved for when you have more time up your sleeve, but an Asian marinade of shoyu and some lemon juice or vinegar can really add some oomph to your dinner. Shoyu is a great condiment either way and provides plenty of flavor to any meal.
Best Substitute if You Have Time: Homemade Ponzu Sauce
What do the best chefs and cooks in Japanese restaurants and homes do? They make their own ponzu sauce. For a truly authentic Japanese experience, you should try making your own ponzu sauce. This is a recipe for confident cooks rather than beginners, but we strongly encourage you to give it a try.
You can make genuine ponzu sauce from scratch with just a few key ingredients.
- Rice vinegar
- Lemon, lime, or orange juice
- Bonito flakes
Some recipes will mix mirin with sake, a rice wine, for a more balanced wine flavor. Mirin is quite sweet so we’ll be using it to balance out the bitter and sour flavor notes in the ponzu sauce. Sake’s stronger flavor might suit you, however, so it really depends on your own personal palate preferences.
Traditionally, the Japanese use yuzu as their citrus component. Finding that in the West is far easier said than done, so we recommend the use of lemon, lime, or orange juice, depending on your own preferences. A combination of lemon and grapefruit juice as an alternative is a great option, and of course lemon juice on its own is a great ingredient, too.
Best Substitute for Taste: Worcestershire Sauce
Worcestershire sauce, even though it comes from the other side of the world, is about as close to ponzu as you can get. Its complex, deep flavor profile might be made from different ingredients, but it fulfils a very similar taste. For example, Worcestershire sauce uses anchovies and tamarind, as opposed to bonito flakes and citrus juice, to provide umami and acidity, respectively.
Maybe Worcestershire sauce was an attempt in the West to copy the delicious flavor of ponzu! It was invented in Worcestershire, England, in the 19th century. Supposedly, the original recipe was too strong in flavor for the delicate English palate. The first batch of sauce was put away in storage, tasted again a year later, and the fermentation process had melloed its taste. The result is the classic Worcestershire sauce as we know it.
Worcestershire sauce is a great substitute for the typical application of ponzu sauce, that is as a dressing or a dip. Its taste is very similar and you can enjoy the balance of bitterness, sweetness, acidity and umami just like with authentic ponzu sauce. It even comes in a similar glass bottle!
Either way, it’s a great substitute.
If you found this cooking resource helpful be sure to leave a comment or give this recipe a rating ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐! I will be happy to hear from you!